My phone was upgraded to android 11, my apps that read and write on Documents folder run well, If I understand well they will stop to run in Aug 2021 for new apps and Nov 2021 for updates. Is it correct ?
Yes that is correct, because writing in the folder
/storage/emulated/0/Documents/ will no longer work on devices with Android ≥ 10 when AI2 is targeting Android 11.
Will they stop to run even without modification on my part ?
No, they will continue to run
Also it has been announced, that we will be able to access shared storage in future, see also
There is currently no component that can save files in the external storage on devices with Android ≥ 10 (outside of the ASD, with the exception of the
File component with
Legacy mode; however, this is ignored under Android 11). In this respect, @patel must have used an extension for saving files in the external storage on devices with Android ≥ 10.
However, this is no longer possible under Android 11 (
WRITE permission no longer exsits under Android 11. Therefore it will stop working on devices with Android ≥ 10 when AI2 targets Android 11 (Aug 2021).
Hello Anke. My File1.LegacyMode block stopped working yesterday. Any suggestions ?
It would really help if you provided a screenshot of your relevant blocks, so we can see what you are trying to do, and where the problem may be.
To get an image of your blocks, right click in the Blocks Editor and select "Download Blocks as Image". You might want to use an image editor to crop etc. if required. Then post it here in the community.
Will send snapshot in 45 mins.
It is pretty simple. My local file procedure where i write or read or check for presence, must start with File1.LegacyMode True in order for File1 to work. It was recommended by you or Anke a few months back with the warning that it was going to stop working in a few month.
I guess a few months was yesterday. On err i check my blocks and LegacyMode block was floating by itself. It was not connected to a File1 control, so AI2 doesnt recognize it any more.
I deleted LegacyMode block and error warning disappeared but rest of File1 blocks failed, can't read/write or check for presence.
This is apparently an error of omission transitioning into nb187 File Scope handling.
There should probably be some extra code at app load time to transition the old blocks and attributes to the new system.
P.S. some manual conversion guidance from @ewpatton would help here in the meantime.
(added to FAQ)
- On Android 10 devices
requestLegacyExternalStoragewill continue to work regardless of
- On Android 11 devices for new apps targeting SDK 30
requestLegacyExternalStorageis ignored /
The block before File1.Delete was File1.LegacyMode=True
As of yesterday, the LegacyMode block was disconnected from the do block, it was on its own on the board.
So the bad LegacyMode block is my fault. I marked the method as deprecated and the blocks editor handles this differently than it used to. I will need to write an upgrader to handle this correctly. In the meantime, you will want to replace the LegacyMode block with this:
I can confirm, my old apps continue to access to documents folder, but I can no longer modify or recompile them.
No solution to date?
Purtroppo..cmq io ho cercato di superare il problema..usando al posto di File..il caro e vecchio TinyDB.
try the SAF extension
2 posts were split to a new topic: Importing a sqlite database in Android 11
Can I list a subdir (Documents) created with filemanager in the asd of my application ?
Yes, but how about just trying this out for yourself before asking any questions here.
(Only two simple blocks are needed for this.)