Stop the Crazy slider

General Discussion
, ,
#1

The value of slider position is stored in firebase as "lim:". This "lim" value can also be changed by the microcontroller. When the microcontroller changes this value, I tried to place the slider's position at that value. When I do this with the microcontroller, the position of the slider goes to the set value. No problem so far. Now when I change the sliders position in the app, it goes crazy like this in video. I sent the value to firebase from the microcontroller as both an int and a string, and the result is the same.

Screenshot_20220906_020724
Screenshot_20220906_020724736×682 91.7 KB

More detail
OK, let me tell you more.
1- I changed the slider position. The microcontroller read the changed value of the Slider from the firebase. no problem...
2- I changed this value from the value it left with the rotary encoder from the microcontroller. According to this new value, the position of the Slider has also changed. no problem.
3. Now I changed the Slider again. and he went crazy

#2

Try the SliderTools extension and use the SliderTools.TouchUp event:

grafik

2 Likes
#3

Why would you do that though If the microcontroller sets the limit automatically?

1 Like
#4

You created a feedback loop:

  1. thumb changes, asks Firebase to change its value
  2. Firebase change is detected, so it tries to update thumb.
  3. go to step 1
2 Likes
#5

Good spot ABG. Also, what happens if the User sends a value manually at the same time as the microcontroller........

1 Like
#6

Keeping Huseyin

  1. How often does the microcontroller send the Limit value to Firebase?
  2. What exactly does the value represent? If it's a sensor value, the values could vary wildly.
#7

The value stored in the firebase can be changed both with the rotary encoder on the microcontroller and with the app.

#8

The value stored in the firebase can be changed both with the rotary encoder on the microcontroller and with the app.

#9

Rotary encoder send the value when interrupt enabled .
It is sending the value at first. Depending on the value, the position of the slider also changes. no problem so far. Now the slider goes crazy when I change the slider.
Rotary encoder. It s like potentiometer that you changed the frequency a radio or volume up etc.

#10

In order to stop a feedback loop, you need some way to mute the feedback for a certain amount of time.

That would involve adding a global true/false variable MUTED, checked by both events and required to be false before propagating an update.

You would also need a one shot nonrepeating Clock Timer to turn off the muting after a second.

Another alternative would be to keep a global variable with prior value(s), to help avoid unnecessary attempts to propagate changes. If the new value matches the old value, don't try to propagate it.

2 Likes
#12

OK, let me tell you more.
1-I changed the slider position. The microcontroller read the changed value of the Slider from the firebase. no problem...
2- I changed this value from the value it left with the rotary encoder from the microcontroller. According to this new value, the position of the Slider has also changed. no problem.
3. Now I changed the Slider again. and he went crazy

#13

The ThumbChanged event is too unsyable to use for this app.

Just poll the thumb position with a repeating Clock.

Show us your new blocks if you changed anything. The old blocks are clearly at fault.

1 Like
#14

I didn't change anything. I will share aia file if kids let me :slight_smile: I couldn't upload the file. I try to upload drive now

#15

Use this extension and send the data in the Touch up event.

1 Like
#16

Here is the project.
Thank you all for your attention .

https://gallery.appinventor.mit.edu/?galleryid=a3200923-fcc3-4edd-9d2a-422b55d0cd99

#17

Thank you. I am going to try it. When kids are sleep. :))

#18

As I already said here: Stop the Crazy slider - #2 by Anke

1 Like
#19

Here is a sample for how to use a Canvas instead of a Slider, to get a TouchUp event, without need for any extensions.
https://groups.google.com/g/mitappinventortest/c/eA_T9NWTa6A/m/SZTS48_FAAAJ

1 Like
#20

Export Project

1 Like
#21

Off course. I see. Both of them are same. I will look all them.
Thankfully.